2016 Pre-Season P4P Top 5


1. Connor Mcgonagle  —  Sophomore  —  Timberlane Reg High School

This is not a difficult choice.  This should not be a controversial choice.  The P4P best in NH High School wrestling is clear.  The conversation around Mcgonagle’s season, much like a year ago, is not what he can accomplish IN state, but out.  The reality is that anything less than a New England title would probably be a letdown.  Aware that putting those kinds of expectations on a kid may be unfair I say this; I believe that level of expectation probably doesn’t even rise to the level of his own.  The biggest challenge Mcgonagle will face this season is himself.  With no peer of equal skill in the state, can he stay sharp enough and focused enough to perform at the highest level come postseason?  I say yes.


2015/16 NHSCA Freshman National Champion (126)

2015/16 New England Runnerup

2015/16 NH D1 & MOC Champion

2015 Lowell Holiday Champion

2014 Super 32 National Champion (MS)

#17 ranked Sophomore by Flo



2. Shayne McCann  —  Senior  —  Pinkerton Academy

McCann enters his Senior season looking for a defining moment on the New England scale.  There is no doubt he is amongst the best in the state.  Chances are good he will win his 3rd straight MOC title this year.  The question is whether he can put it all together and win at the New England level.  Look for an early indicator at Lowell Holidays to see where he is headed.  He has the skills to be an All-New England wrestler as a Senior.


Two-Time NH MOC Champion

Two-Time NH D1 Champion

Multiple Youth New England Titles

Youth All-American

3-Time HS New England Qualifier



3. Tristin Cabinta  —  Sophomore  —  Salem High School

 The surprise of the season last year was the emergence of Tristan Cabinta.  Cabinta moved through a stellar freshman year mostly flying under the radar.  A fantastic performance at Meet of Champions culminated in a pin over a top 10 P4P wrestler to win his first All State title.  Riding the wave of that success Cabinta moved on to New Englands where he was a Quarterfinalist.  His great freshman campaign culminated at the NHSCA Nationals where he was the National Runnerup at 138lbs.  Look for big things out of Cabinta in the years to come.


2015/16 NHSCA Freshman National Runner-up (138)

2015/16 NH D1 & MOC Champion

2015/16 New England Championship Quarterfinalist

2015 Lowell Holiday 7th place

Two-Time Youth New England Champion



4. Wayne Nollette  —  Senior  —  Nashua North High School


2015/16 MOC Champion

2015/16 New England Championship Quarterfinalist

2015 Lowell Holiday 7th place

Two-Time New England Qualifier



5. George Tarwo  —  Senior  —  Concord High School


Two-Time MOC Champion

2015/16 NH D1 Champion

2015 Lowell Holiday 5th place

Two-Time New England Qualifier

7 thoughts on “2016 Pre-Season P4P Top 5”

  1. This is definitely a solid start. I can’t say I agree with all of these but to keep this running I figured I’d throw in some honorable mentions. Someone please correct me if anyone has graduated.

    In no particular order:
    Tyler Sharron, Newport
    Marc Boomhower, Campbell
    Ben Widmann, John Stark
    Chris Munnell, Concord
    Noah Stout, Oyster River
    AJ Pagliarulo, Bedford
    Casey Broadhurst, Timberlane
    Cam McClure, Alvirne
    Dylan Tremblay, Timberlane

    1. Interesting that you include Musgraves who was the JV at the end of last year instead of Pinault who placed in MOCs. Is off-season wrestling the reason? I know they were very close last year, just like Donovan and Kappler at 106. There may be some serious weight cutting in Plaistow to spread out those wrestlers.

Leave a Reply